Provisional scores. These version 2.0 scores come from a rescoring pass still in progress: Report v2.0 and Paper v2.0 are not yet written, and some readings are open to challenge (see the Contribute page). Totals may change before release.

Systems

NEEC scores 23 economic systems of three kinds: 6 configured national economies, 9 comprehensive systems, 8 mechanisms. The kind decides how a threshold written for a whole population is read. Each system has an evidence report, criterion by criterion, and its full scoring documents, linked below.

Compare side by side

Choose up to three systems to set their rows next to each other. Where one system scores at least as high on every criterion and higher on at least one, the comparison says so.

System 1System 2System 3

Configured national economies

An existing or historical national political economy, scored as configured at a stated date.

System	Code	Total	Failures	Tier	Evidence
Centrally Planned Socialism	`CPS`	7.0	16	Structurally Inadequate	Evidence report NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md
Nordic Social Democracy	`NSD`	15.5	0	Potentially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md
State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy)	`CN`	11.5	8	Structurally Inadequate	Evidence report NEEC_StateCapitalism_China_scoring_scratch.md
State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism)	`QA`	10.0	10	Structurally Inadequate	Evidence report NEEC_StateCapitalism_Qatar_scoring_scratch.md
State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism)	`SG`	14.0	3	Partially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_StateCapitalism_Singapore_scoring_scratch.md
Status Quo Market Capitalism	`SQ`	12.5	7	Structurally Inadequate	Evidence report NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md

Comprehensive systems

A design or vision for a whole economy, scored as its own sources specify it.

System	Code	Total	Failures	Tier	Evidence
CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH	`CCO`	17.5	0	Potentially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md
Degrowth Economics	`DG`	15.5	1	Potentially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md
Doughnut Economics	`DE`	9.5	10	Structurally Inadequate	Evidence report NEEC_DoughnutEconomics_scoring_scratch.md
Fully Automated Luxury Communism	`FALC`	11.0	9	Structurally Inadequate	Evidence report NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md
Integral	`INT`	16.0	2	Potentially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_Paper_v1_4.md NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md
Libertarian Minarchism	`LM`	9.5	11	Structurally Inadequate	Evidence report NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md
Market Socialism	`MS`	15.0	1	Potentially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md
Participatory Economics	`PE`	17.0	0	Potentially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md
Stakeholder Capitalism	`SC`	11.0	7	Structurally Inadequate	Evidence report NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md

Mechanisms

An institution, instrument or policy family that operates inside a wider economy without itself specifying that economy.

System	Code	Total	Failures	Tier	Evidence
Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend)	`GEO`	14.0	2	Potentially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_Georgism_LVT_scoring_scratch.md
Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking	`IF`	14.0	3	Partially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_IslamicFinance_scoring_scratch.md
MMT + Job Guarantee	`MMT`	12.5	4	Partially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md
Mutual Credit / LETS	`MC`	14.0	3	Partially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_MutualCredit_LETS_scoring_scratch.md
Ostrom-Style Commons Governance	`OS`	15.0	3	Partially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_Ostrom_Commons_scoring_scratch.md
Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism	`SWF`	15.0	2	Potentially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_SovereignWealthFundStatism_scoring_scratch.md
Universal Basic Income	`UBI`	13.5	5	Partially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_Report_v1_6.md NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md
Universal Basic Services	`UBS`	13.0	4	Partially Adequate	Evidence report NEEC_UniversalBasicServices_scoring_scratch.md

Propose a system to score